Energy Aperture

Value chain · CLM-0002

In plain terms

The summary report says the beam is strongest at the middle of the receiving site, at about 240 watts per square metre, and argues that this makes it safe because sunlight is stronger.

The claim as recorded

The Frazer-Nash executive summary states the maximum beam intensity at the centre of the rectenna is limited to around 240 W/m2, and concludes from that comparison alone that the system is inherently safe for life on earth.

Scope and limits

The word "Thus" carries the entire safety argument, and it rests on an analogy to solar flux rather than on any radio-frequency exposure standard. This claim may be cited as evidence of what the study asserts. It may NOT be cited as evidence that the system is safe.

What it assumes

No assumptions are recorded against this claim.

Where it comes from

SRC-023 Space Based Solar Power: De-risking the pathway to Net Zero, 2021
Quoted verbatim, p17: "The maximum beam intensity at the centre of the rectenna is limited to around 240W/m2, or about a quarter of the intensity of the sun at the equator. Thus the system is inherently safe for life on earth."
Related records
Answers question
QST-001 not published in this release
Contradicts
CLM-0010 At its strongest, the beam is around 23 times the level the international guideline sets for...

Cite this

energyaperture.com/c/clm-0002

CLM-0002, Energy Aperture, as of 2021.

Connected records

Other published records linked to this one. A list, not a judgement.

Also from SRC-023
CLM-0003The report gives the receiving site as an ellipse roughly 7 km by 13 km, and states a beam strength of 245 watts per square metre.
CLM-0005A second figure of 29 watts per square metre appears in the same report, but it measures electricity produced per unit of land, not beam...
CLM-0006None of the five main studies mentions the international radio-frequency exposure limits, or any safety standard, or a restricted area...
CLM-1436A UK study says that one space solar power system would typically deliver about 2 gigawatts to the grid, and it compares this with the...
CLM-1441Documents give the size of the CASSIOPeiA satellite design as anything from 1 to 2 km across. For a full-size version delivering 2...
CLM-1442A 2021 study for the UK government shows one design, CASSIOPeiA, as about 1.7 km across and 2,000 tonnes, sending 2 gigawatts to the grid...
CLM-1443The 2021 study for the UK government says the leading designs need no new materials, but that building them at a sensible cost needs two...
CLM-1444The 2021 study for the UK government concluded that space-based solar power is technically feasible, affordable at a competitive cost per...
More on the source page.
Contradicted by
CLM-0010At its strongest, the beam is around 23 times the level the international guideline sets for the general public, and around 5 times the...